Myrrhee Report - January,
James W.R. OWEN. Mary-Lou OWEN.
The area in which the sighting took place is known as the
Upper fifteen mile Creek Road, Myrrhee. The area is approximately
five kilometres South West of Boggy Creek Road. The nearest township
is Moyhu being 25 kilometres from the area. It is also approximately
55 kilometres South West of Wangaratta. The nearest airport is
situated at Benalla 25 kilometres west of Myrrhee. The area is
On the evening of Monday the 1st of January, 1996, G along
with his wife R and daughter M were camping at the Upper Fifteen
Mile Creek Road, Myrrhee in a Camper van. The property is managed
by a Carl and Lorraine MONSHING who reside a short distance away.
At approximately 2130 hours, G left the camper van and once outside
his attention was drawn to an extremely bright object in the
western sky. He instantly called for his wife and daughter to
come outside and check on the object. G stated that the object
was the size of the moon and on occasions the size of a 50 cent
piece held at arms length.
The object was observed for a period of 35 to 40 minutes and
during this time witnesses stated that the object moved along
a hill in a southerly direction following the contour. The object
then returned to its near original position when first
sighted. This was approximately 60 degrees above the horizon.
It was also stated by M that the object also moved some distance
to the right being in a northerly direction at a very fast speed.
She likened it to an X wing fighter from a STAR WARS Movie and
stated that it was a blur. It then appears that the object set
behind the hills and upon doing this lit the hills up like the
M.C.G. It appeared like numerous spot lights. The object never
re-appeared after this. On this occasion the family never had
a camera. They stated that the dogs at their camp were uncontrollable
and in the end had to be tied up. They also stated that the cattle
in nearby paddocks, were or appeared to be in a distressed condition.
At the time of this sighting the weather was fine, warm and
dry. There was no wind or cloud cover. It appears that after
the object had moved behind the hills a light mist rolled in.
G on this occasion made diagrams of the object. It appears
that the sighting had some effect on the family in relation to
their behavioral moods in as much that G and M became moody and
continually stirred each other up. As stated by R, this is out
of the ordinary for her husband and daughter. G also stated that
he had suffered two severe blood noses. He does suffer nose bleeds
but never to this extent.
On this occasion, G , R and M were again alone at their camp
site . At approximately 2100 hours they were outside and in the
same approximate area observed an object similar to the evening
before. This object was smaller than on the first sighting. Their
attention was drawn to this object due to its brightness.
It was commented by the family that this object was much smaller
than they had seen and it was not behaving in the same manner.
It was stated that on the second and following sightings the
object just set behind the hills. Again at the commencement of
the sighting the dogs behaved irrationally, running about and
barking. The object then set behind the hills at 2145 hours being
much earlier than on the previous sighting.
This sighting had a gathering of eight witnesses. They viewed
this object from the same position as the family had on the previous
occasions. The time was again 2100 hours. They observed the object
appear and as the evening progressed the object grew brighter
as in sighting two. It set behind the hills in the west at approximately
2145 hours as observed in sighting 2. There was no similar behaviour
as in sighting one. On this occasion they had an instamatic camera
and took photographs of the object.
On this occasion Lorraine MONSHING arrived with a Video camera
to film this object. At this stage the Chronicle Newspaper had
been notified and a Mr. David NEWPORT, a journalist for the paper
was to attend but never arrived until after the sighting. The
object again appeared around 2100 hours. Lorraine filmed the
object on and off from different locations around the camp site
until the setting of the object at 2145 hours. Lorraine has stated
that she is no expert with the Video Camera and that on this
occasion the camera was hand held. During the filming the dogs
can be heard barking . As this sighting progressed it appears
that the Instamatic camera commenced to operate without any human
intervention. On the first occasion it was being held by G who
then placed it on the bonnet of the car. The camera then again
switched itself on and extended the telephoto lens. It then switched
off. G then placed it into the carry case and stated that he
could hear it switch on and off again. He stated that the batteries
were reasonably new and that the camera never played up after
this. In the filming G mentioned that this object was similar
to what he had seen. At 2145 hours the object that had been filmed,
set behind the hills. This was not filmed. No comment was made
that the setting was out of the ordinary.
On the evening prior to this sighting, myself and my wife,
accompanied by Mr Robin KIRK a local pilot and an official observer
for the Internationale Federation Aeronautique (A.F.I.) attended
at the camp site. We were greeted by the SIMPSONs and we
obtained details of previous sightings. At this stage there was
heavy rain with quite a lot of lightning. The visibility was
poor. We all decided to follow it through on this evening and
we attempted to take wet and dry temperature checks for inversion
layers. During the evening we observed nothing out of the ordinary.
We then returned to the MONSHING premises where we observed the
Video. We left the area at about 2300 hours.
On the 6th of January, 1996, my wife and I attended at the
camp site at the Upper Fifteen Mile Creek Road, arriving at 2000
hours. Other people were present, keen to see anything out of
the ordinary. A short time later Lorraine arrived with her video
camera and food for the visitors. Whilst at the site others arrived.
The evening was clear with absolutely no cloud cover. It had
been a warm day and as the evening progressed it cooled down.
At approximately 2030 hours I noticed Venus appearing in the
West sky. The sun had not long set and Venus was a light, the
size of a pin head.
As the evening continued Venus grew brighter. I noticed that
this became a talking point among the witnesses. I noticed that
G was continually looking at Venus. I was conversing with him
and during this he stated that this was not the same object that
he had seen on the first occasion. I had set up the telescope
and Venus was viewed through this. I informed G that this object
was Venus and spoke to him about the possibility of this being
what he saw. He stated that this was not the object that he had
seen on sighting one but agreed that it may have been similar
to the other sightings. Lorraine stated that it was or looked
like the object that she had videoed, but was not as red. Venus
then set and nothing unforetold happened.
It was quite apparent that the family was becoming disheartened.
Both my wife and I conversed with them . R was under the belief
that everyone would think she was lying. At this stage we re-assured
them that this was not so. At 2145 hours I recorded that Venus
had set behind the hills . No glow or anything similar could
be seen from the position it had set. During the evening I checked
for inversion layers. There was no layer detectable. I also checked
compass readings with a Prismatic Compass.
As Venus set the Moon could be seen rising behind the camp
site in a north east direction. It was a full moon.
Just prior to 2200 hours, the moon had risen above the hills
and the telescope was directed at the moon. The children present
were using it. As it approached 2200 hours I was looking in the
westerly sky as were others at intermittent periods. It was then
that my attention along with the others in the group was drawn
to the western sky. We observed an extremely bright white light
approximate size of a quarter moon. At first it appeared to travel
towards us at a slow speed and then moved to our right without
changing shape or brightness. The light of the object was similar
to numerous spot lights but were not blinding in any way. It
was possible to look at the light without hurting your eyes.
This cannot happen when looking at spotlights or similar. The
object made no sounds nor was there any flashing lights. At first
it travelled slowly and then at a fast speed ending up as a pin
When the sighting occurred G exclaimed that this was what
he saw on the first night . He also commented and to my surprise
that this object would have landed if there had not been so many
people in the area. I noticed that he was very excited and also
in a way disappointed. During the sighting that lasted approximately
fifteen (15) seconds, I had asked everyone to quieten down and
listen and observe. When asked no one had heard any sound. They
all seemed excited and could not explain what they had seen.
After the sighting Mr Carl MONSHING arrived at the camp site.
He was also quite excited and informed us that he was driving
up to the camp site when he observed an object travelling from
the west towards him. He stated that it looked the size of a
one cent coin and estimated the size as two 707 Jet planes. He
stated that it was a white light and that it dropped behind the
hills faster than anything he had ever seen before. I noticed
that Mr MONSHING continually looked in the western sky once at
the camp site.
We continued to watch the area for some time after. We observed
satellites crossing the sky. Approximately 40 minutes prior to
this sighting, a small plane had been seen travelling in a south
westerly direction. It could be heard and the flashing lights
easily observed. It was in a totally different area than the
actual sighting and was not similar to the object seen. At the
time of the sighting the temperature was 15 degrees C. It was
still a calm night with no wind.
Information has since been received from an Independent person
Mr B from Wangaratta , that he was camping at Middle Creek on
Saturday the 6/1/96. This position is west of the family camp
site on the opposite side of the ranges. He stated that he knows
the area extremely well and knows where the MONSHING farm is
situated from his camp site. He stated that he had read the article
the day previous and decided to stay up and watch the sky. At
2200 hours he was watching the eastern sky when he observed a
red glow coming through the trees. He stated that it was not
flashing . He stated that it was not a plane or a fire and that
he could not explain it. He never saw any object.
I have examined the information collated at this stage and
I will now detail my findings as per sighting.
SIGHTING 1. 1/1/96
The object was seen by three witnesses only. I have no doubt
of their honesty in this matter. I believe that this sighting
is not similar to sightings 2, 3 and 4. On this occasion the
object behaved erratically in as much that it moved along the
contours of the hills and then returned to the near same original
position. This object was observed from 2130 hours and watched
for 30 to 40 minutes which would have the object disappearing
around 2200 hrs to 2210 hrs. The location of this object is in
the area where Venus is observed and sets. I have check the setting
of Venus and it has set no later than 2145 hrs. This is earlier
than the recorded setting due to the hilly terrain. This would
then have Venus setting prior to the completion of the sighting
by some 20 to 30 minutes. If in fact this object is as bright
as the family say then VENUS would not have been noticed as much
and if in fact at all. I have since observed VENUS (SEE SIGHTING
REPORT SIGHTING 5.) and noticed that when it set that there was
no observable light coming from behind the hills. (SEE SIGHTING
Bureau of Meteorology have no explanation as to the size of
the object on this occasion. I have no explanation why the hills
lit up as they did. On this sighting I believe that it should
be considered a U.F.O.
SIGHTING 2. 2/1/96
I believe on this occasion the family were expecting to see
the object and upon observing a very bright light believed that
they were seeing the same object as the night before . Venus
was very bright and as stated by the family the object was a
lot smaller than that of the previous sighting. On this occasion
I believe that they observed Venus appear and set. On this occasion
it cannot be classed as a U.F.O.
SIGHTING 3. 3/1/96
On this sighting the object appeared as it did the night previously
and behaved the same as sighting 2. At no stage did it behave
as in sighting 1. On this occasion photographs were taken. This
object set at 2145 hours. I am again of the opinion that this
object was Venus and thus cannot be classed as a U.F.O.
SIGHTING 4. 4/1/96
On this occasion the object appeared at the same time and
was videoed by Lorraine MONSHING. It was in the same position
as sighting 2 and 3. The object appeared to be in the same position
as Venus and behaved as Venus did. The video is in and out of
focus causing it to behave out of the ordinary. Lorraine commenced
videoing at 2100 hours and during this she moved to other locations
causing this object to appear to move in the sky. I believed
that Lorraine was confident that she was filming something out
of the ordinary and that she honestly believed in what she saw.
At one stage upon examining the tape we observed what appears
to be a plane travelling from the left of the screen to above
the object. It also appears that this plane was closer than the
object. Flashing strobe lights were observable. During the video
you can hear G mention that it was the same object that he had
seen. I believe that he is indicating the 2nd and 3rd sighting
as he stated that this object was not the same as in the first
sighting. On this occasion the camera played up as stated in
the report. You can also hear the dogs barking. The kookaburras
were laughing but at this time of the evening it is normal. The
object set at 2145 hours.
I believe that Venus was the object videoed . I am at a loss
as to why the camera was playing up on this occasion. I am also
at a loss why the dogs were behaving as they did. The only possibility
is that due to the hills and terrain and the limited visibility
of the surrounds, that an object may have been in close proximity.
SIGHTING 5. 6/1/96
On this occasion both my wife and I were present. We observed
Venus appear and set. It set at 2145 hours approximate. I observed
no other bright stars or planets that would attract attention.
At 2200 hours we observed the object appear. I am of the opinion
that this object was not a plane or any other terrestrial object
due to its speed and behaviour This object was observed
by witnesses from different back grounds, and when asked no one
could offer an explanation. No one could actually say from where
the object appeared. Also on the same evening an independent
person on the other side of the ranges observed a red glow. This
is consistent with Carl MONSHING observing the object drop over
the hills. This would have been in the vicinity of where this
independent person was camping. Checks with local airports were
unable to assist with planes in the area. I am of the opinion
that this object is unexplainable and at this stage should be
classed as a U.F.O.
James W.R. OWEN. Mary-Lou OWEN.
Last Updated: March, 1998
Copyright © 1996 Victorian U.F.O.
Research Society Inc.
P.O. Box 1043 Moorabbin Victoria,
This page maintained by VUFORS
About this Web site.