CJA E-letter   

from the Commonwealth Journalists Association  www.cjaweb.com

 

Headquarters: 305 Goodwood Heights, Diego Martin, Trinidad and Tobago

Executive director: Josanne Leonard miribai@tstt.net.tt

Newsletter editor: David Spark david@dspark.fsnet.co.uk, who would like to hear from you. Views expressed in this newsletter are those of contributors, not the CJA

 

The CJA thanks the Commonwealth Foundation for its financial support

 

Issue No 15                                                        May 2006

 

Page 2   World Press freedom: Maldives’ bad record

Page 3   Gambian regime bans The Independent

Page 5   Media coverage at a price in Uganda’s election

Page 6  Cameroon, where press freedom is excuse for licence

Page 7  Rattling Mr Mugabe’s cage

Page 8  Radios promote recovery from Pakistani quake

Page 9  A well-loved broadcaster: News from round the world

Page 10 Books – Pharming, phishing and bitmapping

 

100 apply for CJA’s Thomson course place

 

About 100 journalists from ten countries applied for the CJA-sponsored place on this summer’s three-month print journalism course at the Thomson Foundation, Cardiff. The winner will be announced shortly. Also on offer are scholarships from the Commonwealth Broadcasting Association for TV journalists to attend a three-month course in Kuala Lumpur. Contact bursary@cba.org.uk. Applicants must have worked for at least a year for a CBA member station, and for under three years in broadcast journalism

.

Two shot dead at Tamil newspaper

 

Two staff members of Jaffna’s biggest-selling Tamil newspaper, Uthyan, were shot dead on May 1 by gunmen who destroyed all the computers in its office. Two other staffers were wounded, reports the Free Media Movement. Violence has been growing in Sri Lanka since the presidential election, and the truce between the government and the Tamil Tigers has become fragile.

Maldives among Asia’s worst countries for press freedom, says ARTICLE 19

 

Abdullah Saeed, a journalist working for the opposition paper Minivan in the Maldives, was given life imprisonment in April on a charge of having drugs on him when he answered a police summons. His lawyer says the drugs were ‘found’ after his clothes were taken from him.

 

Minivan subeditor Nazim Sattar faces a six month sentence on a charge relating to an article published last year. Mohammed Yushau, a Minivan correspondent, was arrested in April for allegedly ignoring a summons.

 

The freedom of expression organisation ARTICLE 19 says the Maldives is among the worst offenders in Asia in terms of press freedom.

 

WORLD PRESS FREEDOM DAY

Mahathir’s daughter defies press curbs

 

As World Press Freedom Day, May 3, approached, press freedom found an unexpected champion. Marina Mahathir, daughter of ex-prime minister Mahathir who kept Malaysia’s press on a tight rein, defied press curbs by using her column in The Star to attack a new law. The law makes it easier for Muslim men to marry more than one wife and claim property after divorce (a text message from a mobile will do).

 

Marina’s column is now reported to be censored. Malaysian journalists collected signatures on May 3 in support of a demand for a parliamentary inquiry into press freedom.

 

The CJA’s president, Hassan Shahriar, issued a Press Freedom Day statement in which he pointed out that nearly 500 journalists were arrested and jailed around the world last year. In some Commonwealth countries, he wrote, journalists have been protesting against violations by governments and others. “The media cannot sit idle. They will continue to highlight governments’ incompetence, corruption, mismanagement, lack of transparency and accountability.”

 

In Sri Lanka, Sivaramya Sivanathan, a journalist with the state broadcaster, was arrested at a Unesco World Press Freedom Day conference when she could not produce a conference invitation. Police handed her over to intelligence men to see if she had terrorist links.

 

Uganda’s Human Rights Network for Journalists writes:

Every year headlines and breaking news are reported in both the electronic and print media, with graphic accounts of events at front lines and of the suffering of local populations and combatants. These and many other news items arise out of the hard and courageous resolve of journalists working under the most harsh and perilous conditions without a gun but armed with tools that bring reality to everyone’s doorstep and living room.

 

In Tanzania, the local chapter of the Media Institute of Southern Africa asked the government for a freer flow of information. Its secretary-general, Jamillah Mwanjisi, said: “An independent, pluralistic and free press is essential to democracy in a nation, and for economic development.”

 

The same point was made by a district government chief at a seminar organised by the Rural Media Network Pakistan (picture below). He said that the greater the press freedom, the more likely that money will be spent on development needs. A prize of 5000 rupees was presented to Mazhar Rasheed for his work for press freedom in a small town, Mubarakpur.

 

        

         Seminar in Pakistan              (Right) Ehsan Ahmed Sehar of the Rural Media Network

 

Gambian regime bans The Independent

 

In May, Gambia’s government continued to prevent publication of The Independent, long a thorn in its side. The government offered no explanation and did not seek the court order legally required. An Independent journalist, Lamin Fatty, was still being held

 

The Independent’s general manager, Madi Ceesay, and editor Musa Saidykhan were also detained when police closed the paper on March 28. They were held three weeks, well beyond the legally permissible 72 hours.

Fatty wrote an article headed “23 ‘Coup Plotters’ Arrested”, about an attempted coup. He incorrectly reported the arrest of a former minister.

 

Demba Jawo writes:

The closure of The Independent came immediately after the foiled military coup against the government of President Yahya Jammeh.

 

With the detention of Madi Ceesay and Musa Saidykhan, who are also president and vice president of the Gambia Press Union, the government seemed to have killed two birds with one stone. They not only silenced The Independent but also crippled the GPU, which has been acting as the voice of Gambian journalists.

 

The independent media in The Gambia have endured all types of harassment and intimidation since this government came to power, but The Independent has had more than its fair share of that harassment.  Since it was founded in 1999, it has never been far from trouble, culminating in the torching of its printing press in 2004 by still unidentified arsonists.

 

Everyone is speculating as to why The Independent was arbitrarily closed down by the authorities without their going through the legal process. There is no shortage of possible reasons. The Gambia is gearing up for presidential elections later this year and, since The Independent is the most critical newspaper in the country, it makes a lot of sense for the authorities to find an excuse to close it down.

 

Another possible reason was to silence it during the aftermath of the foiled coup when the government has been using arbitrary methods to deal with those suspected of complicity in the coup.

 

The authorities no doubt know that The Independent has been the most popular alternative to government propaganda among Gambians at home and abroad. Many people have expressed their anger against the closure. A retired civil servant, Ousman Jatta, remarked: “The Independent has been the only newspaper reflecting the views of the common people of this country and any attempt to close it down is tantamount to gagging the people.”

Media cover at a price in Uganda’s election

 

Most candidates had to pay journalists to get media coverage in Uganda’s election, according to the Human Rights Network for Journalists. Those who paid nothing got little or no coverage.

 

Some candidates paid up to 100,000 Ugandan shillings a day. Radio and TV presenters allegedly received up to two million. The Human Rights Network criticises media employers for not paying journalists well enough, and businesses for not using the media to advertise their wares.

 

Government broadcasters are supposed to treat candidates equally but did not do so. The New Vision newspaper covered opposition candidates, on inside pages. President Museveni (the election winner) got the front.

 

However, in addition to independent newspapers, Uganda has 50 radio stations, many of which backed Museveni’s most formidable opponent, Dr Besigye. Some radios tried to provide fair coverage but lacked the cash.

The government put pressure on the radio stations, posting soldiers there on polling day It came down hard on two airing opposition views. Choice FM in Gulu, heartland of the impoverishing civil war, was closed down.

 

A government functionary injured a Daily Monitor reporter in the eye. Before the election, the government expelled from the country Blake Lambert, a Canadian journalist whose coverage it disliked. It gave BBC correspondent Will Ross a work permit for only four months, but extended this to a year when the BBC and the British Foreign Office protested.

 

Cameroon editor beaten at party rally

 

Eric Motomu, publisher and editor of the Chronicle newspaper, was beaten unconscious in May by the driver and bodyguard of the chairman of the SDF, Cameroon’s leading opposition party, reports the Cameroon Association of Commonwealth Journalists. The paper had criticised him for tribalism and dictatorship in his running of the party. The attack happened at a party rally. One of the attackers said: “What have you come here to do? We don’t want you here.”  The previous day, Eric had received a summons for criminal libel for including the party chairman in a list of billionaires. Before he founded the party, the chairman owned a small bookshop.

 

Where press freedom is excuse for licence

 

By Asong Ndifor

 

A visiting diplomat once asked a Cameroonian minister if there was press freedom in Cameroon. The minister took his guest to a kiosk in Yaounde, the capital, and urged him to buy newspapers from among 30 or so on display, all with screaming headlines. The minister said: “When you have read the papers, we can discuss press freedom in Cameroon.”

 

The diplomat joked that, if the papers he read had been published in Britain, they would have been bankrupt from libel damages.

 

Some 200 newspapers are registered in Cameroon. Except for four dailies and five weeklies, they appear irregularly, often with headlines that defy professional decency. It is not unusual to find suspects being called murderers, or to read the headline ‘Kill this man’, with an arrow pointing to a picture of a provincial governor. It is common to see a headline ‘Arrest this man’ and find the reporter is accuser, prosecutor and judge.

 

It was no surprise when some newspapers published a list of 50 government ministers, Catholic priests, businessmen and sports stars and accused them of homosexuality, a criminal offence in Cameroon. The publisher of a paper which came out with the ‘scoop’ produced no evidence and got four months for criminal libel.

 

The Cameroon Association of Commonwealth Journalists has been campaigning for criminal libel to be abolished. But government apologists say it is necessary to deter reckless journalism, especially as the Cameroon media are too financially weak to pay damages in civil libel cases.

 

Many of the 200 papers have no offices, only mobile phones. Print runs average 2000. A lame-duck economy provides little advertising. Many who pass as journalists have no training in journalism.

 

Except for the criminal libel law, Cameroon would have one of the freest presses in the world. But some journalists abuse their freedom, taking it as a licence to injure the reputation of innocent people or settle personal scores.

Rattling Mr Mugabe’s cage

 

Wilf Mbanga, editor and publisher of The Zimbabwean, has been depicted, in cartoons in Zimbabwe, kneeling before Tony Blair and having his head patted, reports Genevieve Roberts in The Independent, London. He takes this and the government’s denunciation of The Zimbabwean as a sign that his independent weekly has got Mr Mugabe’s men rattled. “The government is giving us a lot of publicity through its reaction,” he says.

 

Fifteen thousand copies reach Zimbabwe. Wilf thinks the regime lets this happen to make a show of democracy – most of the country’s media are government mouthpieces. “If I were to publish daily, it would be banned.”

 

Reporters, who write unpaid and under pseudonyms for The Zimbabwean, risk up to 20 years in jail. The regime is battling to stop anyone writing for papers abroad, including The Zimbabwean which Wilf runs from his dining room in England. Its reporters cannot go to press conferences or get government quotes. “They use sources who will not shop them,” says Wilf.

 

In April, The Zimbabwean reported the beating-up of a journalist whom the government suspected of writing for foreign media. Another journalist suspected of working for foreign media was locked up for four days.

 

The Zimbabwean is backed by the Open Society Institute and a Dutch donor, not by the British and American governments as the state-run Herald alleges. It is beginning to earn money from advertising.

 

Wilf Mbanga, once a friend of Mugabe, was first managing director of The Daily News, which Mugabe silenced in 2003. 

 

Commenting on a plan to set up a Zimbabwe Human Rights Commission, Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights says this will be a white elephant unless laws and practices introduced by the Mugabe government are reviewed; These include the Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act and the Broadcasting Services Act which, says ZLHR, have been used to close independent media houses, harass, arrest and intimidate journalists and close independent radio stations and printing presses, ZLHR also complains about the state’s defiance and non-enforcement of court decisions in human rights cases,

Reporter Beauty Mokoba and a cameraman from Botswana’s state broadcaster were arrested by Zimbabwean police near the border on April 30, held for two days and charged with reporting without accreditation. They were reporting on an outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease and the possible role of cross-border cattle rustling in its spread.

 

Pakistan quake: radios promote recovery

 

Since the October 2005 earthquake that killed over 73,000 people and left 3.5 million homeless in Pakistan, a group of local radio reporters have tirelessly covered the disaster and relief effort.

 

They have produced over 120 daily, hour-long, Urdu-language programmes known as Jazba-e-Tameer (Desire to Rebuild). The show, produced by Internews, an international agency that supports media development worldwide, is funded by Britain’s Department for International Development. It is broadcast by seven emergency FM radio stations in the earthquake zone and several other stations.

 

Every day the journalists report on relief and reconstruction work by UN, local and international organisations, and they tell these agencies about local needs. They provide information about health and sanitation, shelter, education and women’s issues.

 

The show has helped dispel rumours. It countered a widespread belief that the quake was divine punishment. It also ended rumours about a possible mass evacuation after a seismic report, and it prompted authorities to restore telephone and power lines in affected communities.

 

The reporters have stimulated public discussion about the disaster and the international community’s response. Each programme is followed by an hour-long, phone-in.

 

Displaced people are now returning to their home communities. The reporters will continue to serve as a link between them and the relief and reconstruction agencies.

 

For more information, Aaron Goodman aaron@internews.org.pk

 

 

The broadcaster who focused on Africa

 

Israel Wamala, well known throughout Africa as editor for 20 years of the BBC programme Focus on Africa, has died aged 71, in his home country, Uganda. Son of an influential chief, he went to Britain to study law and had so little intention of staying that he refused to buy an overcoat. But he dropped into Bush House, headquarters of the BBC World Service, to do freelance work, and embarked on journalism, covering Africa’s wars and coups and struggles from the 1960s till 1988, when he returned home.

 

The Times records that he was a polite but insistent interviewer and an extraordinary boss, always engulfed in tobacco smoke. He wrote scripts on cigarette packets. He could not type and was hopeless at editing tape but he employed aggressive and hard-working young producers. The Focus office was a cauldron of noise as guests popped in from Africa and producers shouted down bad phone lines to correspondents there. Amid the chaos, Israel was always serene and the programmes, somehow, went on air.

 

 

 

News from round the world

 

BANGLADESH

 

A ruling party MP and his supporters forced a press club east of Dhaka to abandon a conference about press freedom and the torture of journalists. Among the scheduled speakers was former CJA London stalwart Ghaziul Hassan Khan.

 

CANADA

 

The newly elected Canadian government banned coverage of the homecoming of four soldiers killed in Afghanisatan.

 

INDIA

 

Six daily paper editors in Manipur state, near the Burma border, were kidnapped by the Kangleipak Communist Party in April. They were released when their papers published a KCP statement. The KCP then ‘banned’ the Imphal Free Press for its handling of the statement. As a protest against all this, the six papers did not publish on April 19.

 

Senior South Asian editors, meeting in New Delhi in March, called for the Geneva Conventions to better protect journalists in strife-torn areas.

 

NIGERIA

 

Nigeria’s National Broadcasting Commission has lifted restrictions on a Kano station, Freedom Radio. The NBC had objected to remarks on talk shows.

 

Alfred Egbegi, publisher of a weekly in the Niger delta, was arrested in April and faces criminal charges, over a report of trouble between a state governor and his deputy.

 

PAKISTAN

 

 

The Rural Media Network of Pakistan held a one-day training workshop (picture above) for 33 writers and students at Ahmedpur East in March. The Bahawalpur district information officer urged his hearers to highlight the development issues facing the 60 per cent of the population who live in rural areas. Another officer said that the media had not managed to keep the public informed about what local governments were doing. They needed help in interacting with local government. He also urged journalists to report both sides of local issues. RMNP convenor Ehsan Ahmed Sehar said that officials were not effectively implementing the freedom of information law. Advocate Rana Sardar Ahmed asked journalists to campaign against abuses of human rights.

 

About 150 TV sets, 210 video recorders and 6000 cassettes were torched by members of a banned movement in Swat, North Pakistan, in March. They said the TVs and VCRs encouraged vulgarity

 

Troops in March silenced with a mortar shell the pirate radio of Mufti Munir Shakir who .has been battling for control in the Khyber agency.

 

According to the Rural Media Network Pakistan, the family of Hayatullah Khan, a journalist who was kidnapped by gunmen in December in North Waziristan, has been told he is being held by the United States. In March, journalists in Islamabad, Karachi and Lahore held a day of action against his disappearance.

 

A photographer lost an eye and six other journalists and a driver were also injured when a bomb went off at a Karachi celebration of Mohammed’s birthday, killing 57 people. The Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists has called for journalists in Karachi and other volatile areas to be supplied with flak jackets and body armour

 

Munir Mengal, head of the TV station Baluch Voice, disappeared when he went to Karachi in April. Four Baluch nationalist websites have been banned but a ban on a blog that used the notorious Mohammed cartoons has been lifted.

SINGAPORE

 

Lee Kuan Yew and Prime Minister Lee Hsein Loong have brought criminal libel charges against 12 opposition members who form the executive of The New Democrat, which is published once or twice a year. An article questioned the government’s handling of a corruption scandal at the National Kidney Foundation. The government commonly uses libel actions to silence criticism.

 

SWAZILAND

 

Musa Ndlangamandla, chief editor of the Swazi Observer, reported threats to his life in April because of a campaign against loan sharks. Moneylenders have threatened to stop lending to Observer staff members.

 

BOOKS

Phishing, pharming and bitmapping

 

Do you have problems with tiffs, jpegs and bitmaps? Can you tell a pharmer from a phisher? All is explained in Tech Terms, a 280-page directory of computing and communications words by Jeff Rutenbeck of Denver University.

 

A bitmap is what the name suggests: an electronic file mapping a picture bit by bit. If the picture has been scanned at 300 dots per inch, the resulting bitmap can be megabytes long. A tiff (tagged image file format) is a similarly large picture file. These big files can be compressed into a jpeg (Joint Photographic Experts Group), from which unnecessary information has been weeded out. The file then becomes easier to store and transmit.

 

Pharming and phishing are forms of ‘social engineering’ – getting people to give away passwords and account details without their intending to do so. Pharmers reroute queries to spoof websites. Phishers use e-mail as bait.

 

And, by the way, http stands for hypertext transport protocol.

 

Tech Terms by Jeff Rutenbeck (Focal Press and National Association of Broadcasters http://books.elsevier.com)

 

VOA seeks African development reporters

 

Bill Eagle of Voice of America is seeking people able to supply audio stories about development in sub-Saharan Africa. Anyone interested can reach him at weagle@voanews.com.

 

Our thanks

 

 

Once again, we would like to thank our contributors and sources, including the International Freedom of Expression Exchange and its affiliates, ARTICLE 19, the Committee to Protect Journalists, the Free Media Movement (Sri Lanka), the International Federation of Journalists, the Media Institute of Southern Africa, Media Rights Agenda (Nigeria) and Reporters Sans Frontieres