Reviews and Listings
A Shadow on the Glass
- Shortlisted for the Aurealis Award for Best Fantasy Novel, 1998.
- WHSmith (UK) Fresh Talent Promotion, May 2000.
- Ottakars Bookstores (UK) SF/Fantasy Book of the Month, May 2000.
- Listed in Sciencefiction.com's Best of 2001.
The Tower on the Rift
- Listed in the Sydney Morning Herald's Best Books of 1998.
- Listed in Sciencefiction.com's Best of 2001.
The Last Albatross
- Listed in The Australian's Best of Summer Reading (2000).
The View from the Mirror Quartet
- Listed in The Year in Review, 1999, Carolyn Cushman, Locus.
Geomancer
- Listed in Recommended Reading, 2001, Carolyn Cushman, Locus
Terminator Gene
- Shortlisted for the 2003 Aurealis Award for best SF novel
Scrutator
- Listed in the Sydney Morning Herald's Best Books of 2003
- Honourable mention, 2003 Aurealis Award for best fantasy novel
Some reviewer's comments:

|
A Shadow on the Glass
- 'An intense story that starts slowly but becomes increasingly compelling. In
a world full of epic fantasy clones, this stands out as a worldbuilding labour of love with
some truly original touches.' Locus.
- 'Those who like quests will enjoy A Shadow on the Glass
A recurring theme of
betrayal - of people, places, and ideas - heightens the tension and increases the plot's
emotional grip. Ian Irvine writes fluently, and evokes a tangible atmosphere. His protagonists
are engaging and all his characters' motivations convincing.' Starburst, UK
- 'Irvine's series opener promises a grand-scale epic fantasy that features a
pair of unusual heroes and a complex world rich in history and variety. For most fantasy
collections.' Library Journal (US)
- 'Ian Irvine is a great find! He writes beautifully about a vast and intricate
world that seems utterly real. His characters are as well drawn as any I've come across in
fantasy. Best of all, none of them are quite what they seem when first introduced: no white
hats, no black hats. I found them refreshing, complicated, and compelling.' Kate Elliott,
author of King's Dragon.
- 'As good as anything I have read in the fantasy genre.' Adelaide Advertiser.
- 'Irvine has built a history and wonderful culture for his vivid world. His
first novel vibrates with originality.' The West Australian.
|
| |
|

|
The Tower on the Rift
- 'Wonderfully deep, fast-paced adventure.' Barnesandnoble.com (US)
- 'High suspense and tense character interaction - great reading!' Van Ikin,
Sydney Morning Herald
|
| |
|

|
Dark is the Moon
- 'Irvine's evocation of landscapes tortured into strangeness by aeons of magical
intervention and cities wrecked by civil strife is crisply visualised; his set pieces of action-a
fight with pirates, a trek through desert, a magical duel-are involving and viscerally exciting;
his characters are complex individuals who grow and change-the semi-villainous Maigraith has become
almost a secondary heroine.' Roz Kaveney, Amazon UK
- 'Dark is the Moon pulled me along like a tidal wave to its powerful ending.'
Hilary Williamson, Bookloons.com
|
| |
|
 |
The Way Between the Worlds
- 'Ian Irvine's hefty four-volume epic fantasy, 'The View from the Mirror', which
concluded dramatically this fall with The Way between the Worlds, features solid non-Eurocentric
worldbuilding, colourful characters, and a twisted plot that stays nicely unpredictable to the
end.' Locus
- 'Hugely ambitious
an epic, tragic tale of history's implacable impact on the
present, full of driven, often unlikable and inept characters, and betrayal. Though well written,
the pace is sometimes erratic
but interest and originality there is aplenty - and action.'
Starburst, UK (4 stars)
- 'An extended fantasy sequence always has to deliver an impressive pay-off; The
Way between the Worlds is the fourth and final volume of Ian Irvine's 'The View from the Mirror'
and brings the quartet to a convolutedly triumphant finale
For someone whose fiction plays so
thoroughly with ethically grey areas, Irvine is also admirable in his preparedness to sort out
endings that feel right; this is a book in which heroes and villains alike get a part of what they
want, but a sort of justice as well. Irvine has brought both a lively intelligence and a keen moral
sense to the heroics and spell-play of the modern fantasy novel.' Roz Kaveney, Amazon UK
|
| |
|
 |
The Last Albatross
- 'Ian Irvine's The Last Albatross is a radical departure from his successful
fantasy series The View from the Mirror, and is the first in a trilogy of eco-thrillers exploring
the not too distant implications of climate change and global terrorism. Being a bit of a greenie
myself, I thought that the action-packed plot of doomsday cults and planetary collapse isn't far from
the truth. Why join Greenpeace when you can sign onto the death lottery and save the planet your
burdensome ecological impact?' Tim Cadman, The Times (London)
- 'A chilling SF suspense story set against a backdrop of 21st Century environmental
depletion and cultural degeneration. Portrays a frighteningly plausible near future and belongs in most
SF collections.' Library Journal (US).
- 'Australia-consciousness in SF and fantasy takes another step forward with this
well-crafted near-future ecothriller
The chase takes place against the well-developed backdrop of an
unpleasantly plausible dystopia
The tension remains high right to an end that suggests a possible
sequel. SF and technothriller fans should dive into this one. Roland Green, Booklist (US).
- 'A faster paced thriller than his excellent fantasy quartet The View from the Mirror.
Your heart pounds with the violence and adventure of the racing plot.' Australian Bookseller and
Publisher.
- 'Frantic action and SF terror
in a world where corruption and technology are
hell-bent on social destruction.' Murray Waldren, The Australian.
|
| |
|
 |
Geomancer
- 'Ian Irvine is arguably the most inventive fantasy author to emerge in recent years.
His The View from the Mirror quartet established a talent not merely for creating intricate new worlds,
but also for populating them with appealing, believable characters. Geomancer succeeds in being a
page-turner of the highest order ... Irvine can now consider himself comfortably ranked next to the works
of Robert Jordan and David Eddings and, more appropriately, the mighty Anne McCaffrey. If further volumes
of the Well of Echoes saga are even half as enjoyable as Geomancer, then you can count me in. Formidable!'
SFX (UK)
- 'Irvine's strength here is that he makes us care not only about the idealistic, wet,
misguidedly ruthless Tiaan, but also about the occasionally vicious and manipulative Irisis and Nish, who
are not merely villains, but products of their unpleasant world somewhat redeemed by their growing regard
for each other. This is, attractively, grimmer and grittier than most fantasy novels with a real sense of
industrial squalor and a society in paranoid melt-down-and with a neatly unpleasant set of twists at the
end.' Roz Kaveney, Amazon.uk
- 'Ian Irvine has produced one of those rarities in the fantasy genre, and that is a
unique, well-thought-out world coupled with a well-written storyline. A gripping read for Irvine fans or
a fresh new series for any other readers.' Enigma (UK)
- 'Readers of Eddings, Goodkind and Jordan will lap this one up.' Starlog (UK)
- 'The magic-science technology and repressive, war-centred social system are strikingly
new, and even those places revisited are interestingly changed. Irvine mixes in plenty of interesting
characters of uncertain moral fibre to create a compelling adventure in a landscape full of wonders.'
Locus.
- 'Irvine imagines the epic landscape through which the characters move in persuasive
detail and describes it powerfully. The misery of the manufactory's oppressed children and fearful adults
is effectively communicated and elaborated. Driven by fear and inadequacy
they cheat, lie and betray
others in the cause of their own ambition, but are nonetheless sympathetically portrayed.' Australian Book
Review.
|
| |
|
 |
Tetrarch
- "Wondrous Worldbuilding". Locus
|
| |
|
 |
Terminator Gene
- "Ian Irvine is a great storyteller." Australian Bookseller
and Publisher
- "One of the best genre writers around - Irvine's considerable narrative powers are brought
to bear in a grim near-future vision of plot and counter plot." Hobart Mercury.
|
| |
|
 |
Scrutator
- "Ian Irvine's Scrutator is the third book in the superb Well of Echoes Quartet.
Don't worry if you didn't read the others: you'll soon be spellbound by a stunning
landscape teeming with mages and monsters." SMH BEST BOOKS OF 2003
- "It is the most engrossing book I've read in years, the lucid prose unfolding an
action-and-suspense storyline featuring wonderfully credible characters." Van Ikin,
Sydney Morning Herald.
|
Reader's reviews (sadly, not all complimentary!) and star ratings can be seen at
Amazon UK
http://www.amazon.co.uk, Amazon US, http://www.amazon.com and Barnes & Noble
http://www.barnesandnoble.com.
|