Food Variety Scores Explained
Definition of food variety scores
Food variety scores
are a method of assessing dietary adequacy based on
the number of different foods consumed within a given
time period. Commonly, a day, a week, month or year
are used as assessment time periods. Foods are broken
into groups preselected by the researcher, and for
each food eaten in the given period; a score of 1 is
assigned. No points are assigned for frequency of
consumption or eating larger portions of the
foods. The above table shows the scoring method
for assessing food variety over a period of seven
days. A score of 30 would indicate that 30 different
foods had been consumed in the week.
The health benefits of food variety
Source: Position Paper: Food
Variety.
Bridget
H-H. Hsu-Hage1, Kristi M. Richardson1,
Rowland Watson2
1. Healthy Eating Healthy Living Program,
Monash University Building 40, Clayton 3168
2. Department of Human Services, Public Health and
Development Division, Melbourne 3000
Overall, the
important question is, what is the health
significance and importance of eating a diet, which
consists of a wide variety of foods? The usefulness
of food variety has been validated in many studies
focusing on dietary diversity, nutrient adequacy and
disease states.
Nutritional adequacy and food variety
One important
factor in establishing the usefulness of food variety
scores is its ability to predict the nutritional
adequacy of various diets. A study by Guthrie and
Scheer looking at the diets of
black and white Americans found that a simple dietary
score could be substituted for the more complex
dietary analysis when looking at nutrient intakes.
Another study by Randall et al found that greater
dietary variety equated with higher levels of
nutrient intake. Similarly, Campbell et al found
relationships between dietary diversity and
biochemical measures of vitamin intake, although this
was not necessarily a predictor of nutritional risk.
Other studies have looked further into the role of
food variety and nutrition related disease or risk.
Nutrition related diseases and food variety
In a broad sense, a
high food variety may be protective against some
diseases, because foods containing toxins will make a
reduced contribution to the overall diet if a greater
range of foods are eaten therefore the risk of
intoxication is reduced.
Food variety has
shown to be beneficial in the prevention of certain
disease states. Specifically, an association between
increased food variety and lower glycaemic response
in both insulin dependent and non-insulin dependent
diabetes mellitus (IDDM & NIDDM) has been found . Also, among subjects with
Type II diabetes, greater dietary variety was shown
to be associated with less macrovascular disease.
The National Health
and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES II)
conducted in the US in the period of 1976-1980 found
that lack of dietary diversity (among different food
groups) was associated with a greater incidence of
cardiovascular disease and cancer. It was also found
that higher all-cause mortality rates were associated
with decreased dietary diversity.
Conclusion
Although different
definitions of what constitutes "food
variety" exist, the basic premise remains the
same. Food variety has been demonstrated to be an
accurate predictor of the nutritional adequacy of the
diet. Research has shown that food variety has
an important role to play in the prevention of onset
of diseases such as diabetes, cancer and
cardiovascular disease. The importance of food
variety in the diet should be emphasised in promoting
healthy eating to the general public.
|